How much celebration is too much over bin Laden’s death?

My son’s 4th-grade class spent some time yesterday discussing how much gloating and celebrating one should do over the killing of Osama bin Laden.

It’s an interesting question.

I’ve gotten a bunch of emails from religious groups asking the same thing.

The National Council of Churches offers: “Osama Bin Laden is dead. Just as Christians must condemn the violence of terrorism, let us be clear that we do not celebrate loss of life under any circumstances. The NCC’s 37 member communions believe the ultimate justice for this man’s soul — or any soul — is in the hands of God. In this historic moment, let us turn to a future that embraces God’s call to be peacemakers, pursuers of justice and loving neighbors to all people.”

An Orthodox (Chabad) rabbi says: “So there’s the irony of it all, the depth and beauty that lies in the tension of our Torah: If we celebrate that Bin Laden was shot and killed, we are stooping to his realm of depravation. Yet if we don’t celebrate the elimination of evil, we demonstrate that we simply don’t care.”

The Rev. Doug Leonard, former pastor of the Reformed Church of Cortlandtown, is now director of the Al-Amana Centre, an interfaith center in the Sultanate of Oman, a Muslim nation. He sent me an email early today that included this:

*****

The news of Osama Bin Laden’s death spread quickly yesterday morning in the coffee shops, streets and offices of Oman and was accompanied by cheerful talk and a sense of relief among Omanis.

Here are two representative quotes I heard yesterday as I spoke with Omani government officials, business leaders and people on the street about the news: “This is a day to celebrate.  Justice has been done today.”

As the day turned to evening in Oman, morning came to America.  I was sitting with some friends from Oman drinking spiced coffee.  They were surfing the internet on their laptops, following the tweets from America and watching You Tube videos of the demonstrations at the white house and ground zero as Americans began their day.  My Omani friends became saddened and confused by as they saw Americans linking the death of Osama bin Laden with a victory against Islam.

One of my friends whose cheer turned to dismay as he saw the American response on line, said, “If a man commits a crime, we punish the man, not his family or his town or the people of the nation he comes from.  Why are so many Americans holding all Arabs and all Muslims in suspicion?”

*****

Now get this.

An email I got this afternoon from the United Methodist Church noted that a British Methodist and hymn-writer has already written a hymn about bin Laden’s death.

It’s called “We Cannot Gloat: A Time for Grief.”

I can’t seem to get the plug-in to download it, but if you go here, you can try or simply read the lyrics from a PDF.

The writer is named Andrew Pratt. According to a bio, he has written several hymns about 9/11 and other tragedies. It notes: “He lost his only son (age 22) in an accident. He feels empathy with people caught up in tragic situations.”

The hymn begins:

*****

We cannot gloat; a time for grief, another mother’s son is dead, and

if that son has killed and maimed, it is the better least is said; but

let us mourn for all the loss, and stand in shadow of the cross.

*****

(AP Photo/Andy Colwell)

Religious reactions to health-care vote coming forth

Health care reform is on its way and religious voices are issuing praise and condemnation.

c_ml_photoAn email blast from Rabbi Michael Lerner and the Network of Spiritual Progressives is barely satisfied with a “partial victory” — they preferred “medicare-for-all” or a single-payer government-run system.

“The greatest critique we have of how the Democrats achieved this victory was that they failed to articulate that principle of caring as the center of their legislative campaign, and hence failed to win over the majority to support the reform, a failure that may yet lead to significant losses at the polls in November,” Lerner writes.

Morna Murray, President of the liberal Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good, says “There is nothing more fundamental to our core Catholic principles than caring for the sick and most vulnerable. These votes today reflect that principle in action.”

On the other side, groups that believe that the reform bill will lead to the public funding of abortions were predictably dismayed.

Father Frank Pavone of Priests for Life is already working on how to counter the legislation:

*****

Yesterday I was privileged to deliver a homily at a prayer service held in the Capitol for members of Congress. I spoke about the fact that authority and power mean service, and that the people whom the legislators serve are not their people, but God’s people. We govern ourselves; our voices matter. Thank God that when legislators take public policy the wrong way, there are ways to remedy that. Let’s get started.

*****

day-gardner-color-scan-4-07.thumbnailDay Gardner, President of the National Black Pro-Life Union, writes: “Polls have consistently shown that America does not want this Healthcare monster for many reasons, yet, it is being shoved down our throats anyway…It’s obvious that Democrats don’t care what MOST of America wants.”

And on and on we go.

And as the health care debate moves into its next phase, the coming immigration reform debate moves closer to center stage.

Tens of thousands marched in D.C. yesterday to call for immigration reform — including some sort of amnesty for immigrants already here illegally. Religious groups were among the key organizers.

The Rev. Derrick Harkins, Senior Pastor of Nineteenth Street Baptist Church in Washington, probably spoke for many when he said: “As we gather on this beautiful and monumental expanse we are grateful that we reflect the very fabric of our nation. At this moment in history, as we look out upon our immigrant brothers and sisters, we are thankful that our nation’s call to be a beacon of hope comes with the continued call to justice and compassion.”

Those who are opposed to amnesty and in favor of tougher border security will soon have their say, you have to think.

ADD: The strongest language I’ve seen on the health care vote comes from Richard Land, president of the Southern Baptist Convention’s Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, who calls this day “tragic.”

“This healthcare legislation will lead to the overwhelming majority of Americans living shorter lives, and experiencing more pain and suffering before they die,” Land writes.

Yowza. Shorter Lives for most. More pain. More suffering.

Land doesn’t stop there, comparing the effect of last night’s vote to that of…Pearl Harbor:

*****

“Liberals across America are rejoicing today over their ‘historic’ victory. My message to them is, ‘Enjoy it while you can.’ This was a Pyrrhic victory of epic proportions. The Japanese pilots who bombed Pearl Harbor won a ‘historic’ victory as well. Their celebrations were cut short six months later when most of them were killed at the Battle of Midway. As Admiral Yamamoto said at the time ‘I am fearful . . . that we have awakened a sleeping giant and filled him with a terrible resolve.’